Of Justina Robson's brilliant near-future thriller, Mappa Mundi,
.jpg)
"Mappa Mundi is an excellent second novel, with great characterisation and an intriguing plot idea. It's certainly worth reading and Justina Robson is an extremely promising writer but I felt this book strayed a bit too far in its extrapolation to function as a great thriller. As it is, it's simply a good book."
Not arguing with a good review - just feel compelled to add that I love the "straying." For me, the book starts off like any Michael Crichton thriller, but goes in the opposite direction. So much of his work - as well as the Hollywood treatment of SFnal tropes - is about putting genies back in the bottle, while we science fiction types know that that is rarely possible...
.jpg)
"There are some excellent stories here. In his introduction, Anders mentions that he aspires to produce a similar collection to that of Damon Knight's prestigious Orbit series that was so influential in its twenty-one volumes. This is heady competition to put onto a new publication but happily it isn't too difficult to see Fast Forward becoming a similarly established name in original SF anthology history.... Fast Forward 1 has more than enough original and exciting new stories to make it important reading and worthy of more than a couple more editions to follow. Lou Anders has done a good job with this first volume and I hope he continues producing original anthologies if they are as good as this one."
No comments:
Post a Comment